John McWhorter: Txtng is killing language. JK!!!

100 Replies to “John McWhorter: Txtng is killing language. JK!!!

  1. This is too long. I'm texting during it.

    Get to the point. We text because we are forced to. Every one takes too long to talk about things that don't matter and aren't funny enough to hold our attention. 

    What is this slash business. 

  2. Hey everybody! I would greatly appreciate if you could fill out this quick 5-10 minute survey on texting for my language seminar. Thank you so much for your help and your time!

  3. We live in the technological era. The development of technology grows at an exponential rate, and we are currently in the wave of constant technological advances that are hugely changing what it means to be a human. We evolved to survive as hunter and gatherers, but now the main thing you have to worry about is how much green paper you can collect by spending most of your existence in some place you don't want to be. This guy was too late to the party, but for the younger people who grew up on the internet, we are different then those who grew up having to looks things up in an encyclopedia…man I could keep going to reach my point but I'm high as a kite on marryhwonna. Give me a thumbs up if you made it this far. Have an excellent day, my friend!

  4. Danny P. Ruiz "Poorly spoken/written English doesn't become a language.  That would be like saying 2+2=5 and when you're corrected just saying 'It's my new version of math'"

    I can prove that 2+2 does not equal 5.  Can you even define what constitutes "poorly spoken/written English" and then prove that it doesn't constitute a language?  What we speak right now IS the "poorly spoken/written English" that has accumulated over its entire history. 

  5. He's quite right about the fact that our writing evolves inasmuch as our speaking, and that texting is essentially fingered speaking.

  6. I don't think most people even use text speak anymore, a lot of people just use emojis and regular conversational English.

  7. I really don't understand, if texting is limiting/ruining your writing skills you have the capacity to study and expand your grammar, vocabulary etc. if you don't have the capacity you can get help.
    if texting is limiting your communication, or face to face, skills then you have to put the phone down and start to slowly get the confidence to talk to people. You can do this by watching videos or getting ideas/opinions from friends/teachers. You have the ability and resources to perfect your communications skills, why make up excuses?
    Of course this may not apply to people with anxiety, or other problems, since it may be harder for them.
    Also, of course it is easier said than done.

    Please correct me if I'm wrong and any other thoughts are welcomed. ^^

  8. I think about capital letters and punctuation in texting…but I'm the only person I know who texts in "written English".

  9. Idk, wtf ?, lmfao, hru ?, that's the extent of my consciouness 7 lingiuitic skills, except for that sentence, well, and that one too, LOL

  10. I think this is a brilliant view of how communication and language evolves over time. Looking at texting as "fingered speech" and developing multi-lingual skills is a great observation. As a communication instructor, if I can get over the fact that you're not necessarily thinking about punctuation and capitalization while texting, then so can everyone else.

  11. Alright, I'm a little disappointed to be honest. Language is speech and writing? I find your theory to be very limiting to what language really is. I like your observation of the uses of 'LOL', but I highly suggest you check out Mahboob's Model of language variation; he discusses his view of language and grammar and wonderfully describes the different deminsions to variation within the language (i.e. users, uses, mode, and time). This could help you develop a better understanding of why teens text the way they do now and how they develop a shared understanding of the uses of certain language.

  12. I listened to him in a language series on Audible… He looks so different than I thought he did. Still a brilliant man… my fav

  13. I'm afraid that McWhorter's stance on texting asserts that there's no correct way to use the English character set; and that's an egregious error. With the texting technology we possess and all of its auto-correction, suggestion, and SWYPE glory, there's even less of an excuse to write poorly.

  14. I write and text properly out of respect for my reader, and I expect the same respect.

    Things such as LOL, IDK, IKR, OMG, BTW, BRB, TTYL, LMAO, TF, WTF, et cetera indicate laziness or tiredness of thought. They offer very little insight or intellectual value. If you're so rushed or pressed for the time and energy it would take to say something meaningful, perhaps you should get some rest or focus on your pressing task at hand.

  15. I'm 21 and the slash is new to me(at least in the texting sense). I just double text, hit enter a couple times or if I really dgaf just start after the punctuation mark

  16. evolution is inevitable….
    should humans exist beyond a certain point… speech may very well become obsolete as the brain morphs into communicating by means of neuro transmission.

    however…the bridge between that and now seems to be the present reality called TXT'ING…truncating the written words into simple emojis' and simple characters.

  17. I've never heard of slash, that's a situation when you would normally just send the second part as a different text…

  18. John do you know this coincidence in Portuguese language? In Brazil we have a word "né" that is the contraction of the expression "não é" which means "isn´t it?". Japanese imigrants and their descendents love it!

  19. I love John McWhorter and his lecture and speaking style, but you really could make a drinking game out of the number of times he says, "and so for example" in his lectures and talks.

  20. He's not saying it's not possible to text in proper English. What he's saying is that you should judge texting the way you judge speech, not writing. Young people aren't idiots. One doesn't text one's boss with the same casualness one would text a peer or a friend, just as you wouldn't SPEAK to your boss the same way you would speak to a peer or a friend. If you do know someone who is doing that then yes, they need to be corrected, but I would bet the majority have more common sense.

  21. John, I wonder if you look back on this and wish you would have been more concerned about the growing informality of language now that Trump is your President.

  22. Internet chatrooms have also evolved their own sort of parlance and casual dialogue in written form. When I'm online with people over chat platforms like Discord, we have a mixture of conversational English and chat slang. Some of the people I chat with use more slang then others, and among my group of college aged artist/writer peers online we have a variety of slang that tends to show up more in online chatrooms than in mobile texting conversations like "babbin" or "swol" or "fingerguns" or "chinhands" or even just a good old fashioned "keyboard smash," like so… "amuhvfgdcfrcxzesr."

  23. I have always thought people who say texting is killing language need to put their critical thinking caps on.

  24. So right. I LOVE text, twitter FB and YouTube speak and find it fascinating. I have always thought people who say texting is killing language need to put their critical thinking caps on.

  25. 8:15 "Slash" used this way in texts, I have never come across this before. I'm wondering if this is an age thing. I am 43.
    Please reply with whether or not you have come across this before and include your age.

  26. Wow yeah it flicks back and forward like conversation. Like chat. We call it chat. When I want to say I am actually laughing I say "really LOL I am actually laughing" is there a quicker way to say that?

  27. Dr. McWhorter is, in my opinion, the best linguistics teacher around. He is really interesting to listen to, and he can teach you a lot. Not only is there linguistic knowledge and expertise in what he says, but there is also wit and knowledge of what is going on in the world in general. I suggest that everyone purchase and read his many books, and also buy the 4 courses he offers as part of the Great Courses series of The Learning Company. You won’t be disappointed. This man has a lot to teach, and he does so with grace, charm and unbridled efficacy.

  28. Never ever heard of slash. Made me cringe when I heard this guy label me as using it lol <pragmatic particle – lol <acronym

  29. This gave perspective. Often we do judge those by how well you "text" to one another. The use of a word vs the amount of commas he used. Also, I don't use lol as much of a marker but more the mood I am in. For example, if I know my text could possibly be taken negatively, I put lol. I never used slash, tho

  30. So texting is adapting to compensate for the lack of intonation and body language to convey meaning and emotion more efficiently, with or w/o EMOJIS…

  31. Not really worth the time it took to watch.

    It was cringe inducing when he mispronounced Japanese "ne" as he was signal how knowledgeable he is. He should have gone with the Canadian "eh" which is more relatable to English speakers and doesn't come across as trying to be a show off.

  32. Look y'all. It's so simple. All communication is about transferring an internal idea from one person to another. Whether you act it, speak it, write it longhand or type or text or use hieroglyphics, the object is to "get a point aross". Therefore, what is most and only and all important is clarity and accuracy of your meaning to the other and their reception of that in ALL FORMS. So, if you text or speak or type an ambiguous communique which results in a misunderstanding, you have failed. Texting, by nature shortens the means, the modality of communication and therefore it will most probably truncate accurate meaning. But if all you want to say is OK, or LUV YA, then it's fine as a medium. So, best to use each communication form as appropriate for the depth of message required. Text if you can be clear via that medium; talk if you need a discussion; write if you want to document a well reasoned exchange.

  33. He keeps on saying "… texting is …". Well yes and no. Texting is what you make of it, how you choose to use it. HIS DEFINITION of texting is the trendy, youthful abbreviated style, not the way I use it. It only takes the form of the user, not some absolutist system.

  34. As "fingered speech", the danger is that the progression of texting bleeds into a generation of kids who know no other form of communication other than texting itself, a texting kind of talk, and a texting kind of long form writing which is highly abbreviated, thrifty, and therefore vague and ambiguous and practically meaningless.

  35. What I don't like about texting is that it misses the subtleties of speaking that clarifies the misunderstandings that can arise from texting. I still don't understand why texting is better than talking on the phone.

  36. The meaning of lol hasn't changed, it is the stupid kids who are barely educated in anything who butcher the English language, and people like you think English is evolving. It is devolving.

  37. So that one black man who educated himself and can speak properly is pandering to the ghetto babble/internet lingo/poor immigrant English. Such people will drive the western culture into ruins.

  38. I agree with everything here. But I gotta point out: Christopher Hitchens casually spoke in beautiful, eloquent prose paragraphs

  39. the pragmatic particle "nuh?" is used in some dialects of German (Schwabish, I think, maybe others) at the end of sentences. It's used the same way that Americans use "right?" Or the same way that "eh?" is stereotypical in Canadian. There are some (gruesome) videos here on youtube about the WWII bombing of Dresden, and one of the witnesses who is interviewed uses "ne?" all over the place during her responses.

  40. im a teen (16) and this is super true i use texting slang such as lol all the time and most of the time i don't even realize it or the implications behind it. also there's differences between subtle slang such as "haha" and "ahaha" and the like, or "lolll" and other things that's just come to be so natural for my age demographic that we don't realize it! so interesting, thanks for sharing

  41. When I text someone, I take the time to use proper punctuation and grammar. Call me old fashioned, but even in texting.. I text like I'm writing.

  42. Yes, he's right. Then, I've run into English professors who are teaching students this sort of nonsense is part of cultural diversity and identity politics, the milieu in which it is used. Nonsense.

    Technology is as much a curse as a blessing.

  43. In the spirit of Norma Loquendi (“Consuetudo, jus et norma loquendi…” : The right method of speaking and pronouncing is established by custom… ), one almost has to accept that language usage levels and forms will multiply and ramify with the emergence of new platforms. Those of us who have lived through six or seven decades would be well advised to maintain the closest possible ties with our grandchildren – they may laugh at us, but they can also assist us in our effort to remain au courant.

  44. Oh, academic people…. Always intellectually bringing the dumbing down of society into a relativistic prism

  45. I wonder if the slash arises from folks using voice to text. they might type a / symbol to change subjects but if they're dictating and say "slash" the v2t might just insert the word there rather than the symbol. then it becomes a thing

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *